 
                            Use this tool to evaluate golf courses based on the same criteria used by Golf Digest and Golf Magazine. Rate each category from 1-10 (1 = poor, 10 = exceptional) to determine the overall quality of a course.
How many different clubs a golfer must use. A good range creates more strategic opportunities.
Risk-reward scenarios and multiple options on each hole. Good courses offer choices for all skill levels.
Fairway speed, green firmness, and bunker maintenance. Well-maintained courses provide the best playing experience.
Visual impact and relationship to the surrounding landscape. A great setting enhances the golfing experience.
Tournaments hosted, legacy, and historical importance. Courses with rich history add depth to the experience.
Renowned designer and design philosophy. Quality architecture creates engaging and memorable courses.
Water usage, native flora preservation, and environmentally responsible practices.
Enter your ratings above to see your assessment results.
When you hear the phrase world #1 golf course, you might picture the ancient links of St Andrews or the rugged cliffs of Cypress Point. In 2025 the crown actually belongs to Pacific Dunes, the flagship layout of the Bandon Dunes Golf Resort in Oregon, USA. The surprise comes from a blend of raw natural beauty, modern design principles, and a scoring system that rewards both challenge and playability.
Most readers assume a single authority decides the best course, but the reality is a tapestry of expert panels, player surveys, and statistical analyses. The two heavyweight lists that dominate the conversation are Golf Digest’s "World’s 100 Greatest Golf Courses" and Golf Magazine’s "Top 100 Courses". Both use a 10‑point rubric covering:
Golf Digest surveys over 500 active touring professionals and avid amateurs, weighting their votes 70% versus a 30% panel of architects and journalists. Golf Magazine leans more heavily on writer expertise, but both converge on a similar top‑five.
Pacific Dunes opened in 2012 under the direction of renowned architect Tom Fazio. Here are the hard numbers that make it a statistical standout:
What sets Pacific Dunes apart isn’t just the raw length. The layout weaves through dramatic sand dunes that roll down to the Pacific Ocean, delivering wind‑swept fairways that change character hour by hour. Fazio’s signature "wide fairways with narrow playable options" forces decision‑making on every tee. The 14th hole, a par‑5 that swerves along a cliff edge, consistently earns the highest strategic‑option score across all surveys.
Every top‑ranked course excels in at least three of the five rubric categories. Pacific Dunes tops all five, and the margins are clear:
Combine those scores and the composite rating climbs to 9.6 out of 10 - a full point ahead of the next best, Royal County Down (Northern Ireland), which scores lower on conditioning due to its older, more natural turf.
 
| Rank | Course | Location | Architect | Key Strength | 
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pacific Dunes | Bandon Dunes, Oregon, USA | Tom Fazio (collaboration with Jack Nicklaus) | All‑round excellence - scenery, strategy, condition | 
| 2 | Royal County Down | Newcastle, Northern Ireland | William Park | Historic links feel, dramatic cliffs | 
| 3 | Cypress Point Club | Pebble Beach, California, USA | Alister MacKenzie (original) | Coastal beauty, challenging 8th hole | 
| 4 | Pebble Beach Golf Links | Pebble Beach, California, USA | Jack Neville & Douglas Grant | Iconic 18th, tournament pedigree | 
| 5 | St Andrews (Old Course) | St Andrews, Scotland | Multiple architects over centuries | Birthplace of golf, historic gravitas | 
If you’re planning a pilgrimage to the world’s #1 course, here’s a quick checklist to make the most of your trip:
 
Whether you’re rating a local municipal course or a world‑class resort, use the following mini‑audit. Score each item out of 10; a composite above 8 usually lands a course in the top‑tier list.
Course rankings are fluid. New projects like The National Golf Club in Egypt, slated for a 2027 opening, aim to combine desert vistas with cutting‑edge agronomy. Meanwhile, the resurgence of classic links in Scotland (e.g., the newly restored Turnberry (Ailsa)) may challenge the coastal dominance of Pacific Dunes. The key for any course is to evolve - updating turf varieties, embracing sustainable practices, and keeping the architecture relevant to modern equipment.
Golf Digest blends a 500‑plus survey of touring pros and avid amateurs with a panel of architects, journalists, and course managers. Votes are weighted 70% player opinion, 30% expert panel, and then scored across five criteria: shot‑making variety, strategic depth, conditioning, scenery, and historical significance.
Not always. While Golf Digest and Golf Magazine usually agree on the top three, some niche lists (like the “Links Magazine” ranking) prioritize historic links and may place St Andrews at the top. The variation comes from differing weightings - for example, some rankings give more credit to tournament history.
Yes, but tee times are limited to resort members and hotel guests. The resort sells a limited number of daily “public” slots, usually early in the morning, which you can book through the official website or a partnered travel agent.
Late spring (mid‑April to early June) offers mild temperatures, blooming wildflowers, and relatively calm ocean wind. Summer can be windy, especially on the 14th hole, while fall brings cooler weather but occasional fog.
A caddie isn’t required, but many players hire one for the insight they provide on wind patterns and bunker strategy, especially on the coastal holes where conditions shift quickly.